Safe Repairs ~ Save Lives
Campaign Update · Final Rules AdoptedTexans Spoke Up. TDI Listened.
On November 4, 2026, the Texas Department of Insurance adopted its final appraisal rules — and they keep the choice of how an umpire is selected with the policyholder. Thank you to every Texan who sent a letter and signed the petition, and thank you to TDI for hearing policyholders out and acting on what they said.
The original proposal would have let insurance companies control the umpire selection process in claim disputes. Two of the four changes Texans asked for made it into the final rules. See what changed
Texans Made Their Voices Heard
Every dot is a Texan who spoke up. TDI adopted the final rules on November 4, 2026 — thank you to everyone who participated.
Read every comment ACS filed with TDIThe Issue — and What Changed
What the proposed rules got wrong, what Texans asked TDI to fix, and how each ask landed in the final rules.
Insurers would have gained control of the process
The insurer — not the insured — would have controlled which umpire mechanism was used by default.
Nothing required insurers to disclose financial ties to the vendors they listed in the policy.
The insured would have been forced to split the cost of an umpire the insurer essentially chose.
These were the three concerns in the letter Texans sent to TDI between May and June 2026.
Restore fairness for policyholders
The insured should have the sole right to choose the umpire selection method at the time of dispute.
AdoptedThe insured should retain the contractual option to seek judicial appointment of an umpire.
AdoptedInsurers must disclose financial relationships with listed vendors in the policy itself.
Not adoptedIf a vendor mechanism is used, the insurer bears the full cost — not the insured.
Not adopted
Two of the four asks made it into the final rules. See what TDI said about each one
TDI Adopted the Final Rules — Here's What Changed
On November 4, 2026, the Texas Commissioner of Insurance adopted 28 TAC §§5.9800–5.9806 with changes made in response to public comments. TDI reported comments from 204 commenters — including Auto Claim Specialists and 168 individual Texans — and 18 people testified at the June 2, 2026 hearing. Two of the four changes Texans asked for made it into the final rules.
- Adopted
- Nov 4, 2026
- Effective
- Nov 24, 2026
- Insurer compliance
- Mar 1, 2027
- Commenters
- 204
- Ask 1Adopted
The insured should have the sole right to choose the umpire selection method at the time of dispute.
TDI rewrote the vendor provision. A policy may still offer a vendor-based umpire option, but only the policyholder can invoke it — the insurer cannot. TDI also dropped the proposed insurer-built list of multiple vendors.
- Ask 2Adopted
The insured should retain the contractual option to seek judicial appointment of an umpire.
Every appraisal provision must allow either party to request judicial appointment through a county or district court. TDI confirmed judicial appointment is the standard method whenever the appraisers cannot agree, unless the policyholder chooses otherwise.
- Ask 3Not adopted
Insurers must disclose financial relationships with listed vendors in the policy itself.
TDI said a vendor-disclosure requirement was outside the scope of this rulemaking. Its answer: a policyholder who doubts a vendor’s independence can simply decline the vendor option and request judicial appointment instead.
- Ask 4Not adopted
If a vendor mechanism is used, the insurer bears the full cost — not the insured.
TDI declined to shift vendor or umpire costs to insurers and declined to cap umpire fees, saying the policyholder-only trigger for the vendor option already addresses the cost and fairness concern.
Summarized from TDI's adoption order and its published responses to commenters. Read the full order (PDF)
The Letter Texans Sent to TDI
The public comment period has closed. Below is the letter that Texans submitted to TDI.
The Letter
[Your Name] [Street Address] [City], [State] [ZIP] [Phone] [Email] [Today’s Date] Office of the Chief Clerk, MC: GC-CCO Texas Department of Insurance P.O. Box 12030 Austin, Texas 78711-2030 VIA EMAIL: ChiefClerk@tdi.texas.gov Re: Comments on Proposed Rule 28 TAC §§5.9800–5.9806, Docket No. 2862 Texas Department of Insurance, I was recently made aware of an alarming proposed TDI rule that allows insurance companies to include vendor-based umpire selection methods in an insured’s policy — meaning insurers could effectively hand-pick the pool of umpires used to resolve disputes between insurance companies and the insured. These vendors have a financial incentive to favor the insurers who put them on the approved list. And under the current rule language: 1) The insurer — not the insured — controls which umpire mechanism is used by default. 2) There is no requirement that the insurer disclose whether a vendor is financially tied to them. 3) The insured will be required to split the cost of the vendor-based umpire that the insurance company essentially chose. This defeats the purpose of the appraisal process entirely. I propose, as do many others, the following: 1) The insured should have the sole right to choose which umpire selection method is used at the time of any dispute. 2) The insured should have the contractual option to seek judicial intervention to appoint an umpire if so needed. 3) Insurers should be required to disclose any financial relationship with listed vendors, in the policy itself. 4) If a vendor mechanism is used, the insurer should bear the full cost — not the insured. I respectfully request that TDI take my consumer protection concerns into consideration and strongly petition that the long-standing judicial selection of the umpire option be retained as a contractual right when the parties disagree. Please forward this to persons responsible for making decisions about the proposed rule(s). If you should need me for further comments, please reach out to me at the contact information listed below. Thank you for your attention. Sincerely, [Your Name] [Street Address] [City], [State] [ZIP] [Phone] [Email]
The Public Comment Period Has Closed
The window for submitting comments to the Texas Department of Insurance closed at 5:00 p.m. Central on June 8, 2026. Thank you to everyone who made their voice heard for Texas policyholders.
The Petition Texans Signed
Petition to the Texas Department of Insurance: Protect Policyholders' Right to a Fair Appraisal
We, the undersigned Texas policyholders, call on the Texas Department of Insurance to amend its proposed rule under Docket No. 2862 to ensure the appraisal process works for policyholders — not insurance companies.
When we file an insurance claim and disagree with our insurer's valuation, we have the right to a fair, independent appraisal. The proposed rule undermines that right by allowing insurance companies to pre-select the vendors who appoint umpires in our disputes — creating an obvious conflict of interest — while leaving us to foot part of the bill and keeping us in the dark about financial ties between those vendors and our insurer.
This is not what the Texas Legislature intended when it passed SB 458. We demand that TDI adopt rules that:
- Give policyholders — not insurers — the sole right to choose the umpire selection method at the time of a dispute
- Preserve our right to seek judicial appointment of an umpire
- Require insurers to disclose any financial relationship with listed umpire vendors, in the policy itself
- Require insurers to bear the full cost when a vendor mechanism is used
Texas policyholders pay their premiums in good faith. We deserve a dispute process that is genuinely independent and transparent.
Learn More
Auto Claim Specialists' Advocacy RecordEvery comment letter, article and supporting document ACS filed or published on the way to the final rules.